Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Kale Cobb Salad
Pesto Chicken Panini
Rooster Street Beef Burger
Cali Keto Flipper
About
Tomato Pie Cafe
Welcome to Tomato Pie Cafe, a delightful addition to the vibrant breakfast and brunch scene in Lititz, PA. Nestled at 23 N Broad St, this café is not just another eatery; it's a haven for tomato lovers and food enthusiasts alike. With a menu that beautifully merges traditional and modern culinary techniques, Tomato Pie Cafe offers a range of delectable options from savory breakfast pies to mouth-watering sandwiches and salads.
Step inside and you'll find a cozy and casual atmosphere, perfect for families and friends gathering for a meal. The café features outdoor seating for those who enjoy their brunch amidst nature, alongside charming interior decor that adds a touch of elegance. Plus, with amenities like free Wi-Fi and gender-neutral restrooms, Tomato Pie Cafe is a welcoming space for everyone.
- Breakfast Pies: The highlight of the menu is undoubtedly the signature Tomato Pie. It’s not pizza! This unique creation showcases perfectly seasoned fresh red tomatoes baked in a flaky pie shell and topped with a harmonious blend of cheeses. For those with dietary restrictions, the Gluten-Free Tomato Pie ensures no one misses out on this savory experience. While one might expect the classic flavors, this dish stands out with its fresh greens and savory herb scone that accompany the pie, enhancing the overall brunch experience.
- Sandwiches: If you’re in the mood for something hearty, the Meatball Parmesan Panini is a must-try, featuring tender chicken feta meatballs bathed in rich red sauce, all layered between crispy ciabatta. The TCP Grilled Cheese Sandwich paired with a warm cup of soup makes for a comforting meal. Don’t skip the option to add bacon or roasted garlic mushrooms for that extra flavor punch!
- Artisan Lattes: For beverage enthusiasts, the cafe's selection of lattes, like the alluring Maple Bourbon Latte, adds a creative twist to your morning routine. Each sip is a delightful journey, enriched with flavors crafted from scratch.
Customers rave about the Tomato Pie, with one reviewer stating, "You cannot go wrong with the Tomato Pie Cafe. Absolutely the BEST tomato pie ever." Such testimonials underscore the café's commitment to quality and taste. While some guests mention limited parking and longer wait times, the consensus is clear: the experience is worth it. The warm service and inviting ambiance create an enjoyable atmosphere that complements the stellar food.
If you’re looking for a delightful bite to kickstart your day or a leisurely brunch stop, Tomato Pie Cafe promises not only a meal but a culinary experience that highlights the versatility of tomatoes in unexpected ways. Whether you’re dining in or opting for takeout, be assured that every dish comes with a splash of creativity and a touch of love.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Good food, limited parking and usually a long wait but it is worth it. I'd like to see better side options with the meals and the portions might leave you a tad hungry but overall good place would recommend ”
“ This place was incredible! If you don't like tomatoes, try their tomatoe pie! Excellent seasoning for all the food as well! Don't skip the maple burbon latte this month! Cute inside and fancy touches. ”
“ You cannot go wrong with the Tomato Pie cafe. Absolutely the BEST tomato pie ever. YUM! Either eat in or take it to go, the tomato pie is an experience for all to try. Even if you dislike them, you will love them after one bite. ”
“ Tomato pie was a nice savory brunch. It came with a scone that had a great texture. Wouldn't recommend the carrot fries. Service and atmosphere were fine enough. ”
“ Great food, lovely service. I tried tomato pie for first time ever, it was delicious! My hubby had breakfast bowl, really enjoyed it. Menu has nice amount of choices, something there for everyone weather you have sweet or savory tooth! ”
“ Third or fourth time here. Always a pleasure, came on Mother's Day actually around 2:30 so we got seated right away. The interior design is very comforting, historic and homey as if you're eating at home with family, a charming and quaint little cafe with surprising amount of space. Unfortunately limited outdoor space but they do have seating outside! Had the pleasure of doing both indoor and outdoor and highly recommend both! Food is ALWAYS delicious. I'm the biggest fan of their tomato pie (think of like a cheesy, tomato combo with a flaky pastry crust)! I crave it from time to time! It's always hot, melty, buttery and delicious. They had a limited menu this day but we still enjoyed all our dishes. My husband got the tomato pie flipper and finished every crumb! They also have the most delicious drinks if you like fancy coffee and chai combos, some fresh fruit lemonades too! Service is always top notch. Such kind and attentive staff, always greeting you with a smile! We never have complaints here. Overall, this is a MUST visit if you're in Lititz. Great family spot, great for couples and all. Highly recommend. We will gladly continue to be a regular here! ”
“ As usual pretty busy even for a weekday around noon. Not a long wait, and seated next to the window on hwy 501. The mini pie starter was a good choice ( if you haven't had one your missing out) I also got the curry chicken salad , far too much for lunch with the starter big chunks of chicken with cranberrys onion and celery, not too spicy and a herbed scone. Spouse got the double tomato pie so she would have leftovers. Reasonable for a touristy town at$30 or so. Breakfast is served all day until 3 pm or so. ”
“ Beautifully repurposed house. Loved the decor but the food was the real star.the beverages were warm and flavorful. My favorite among our three dishes was the grilled pear but all dishes were very good. I have been wanting to get here for years and it didn't disappoint. Service was attentive and excellent, even in the midst of the holiday season. ”
